When someone does something that causes serious harm, it's natural to judge their actions. We want people to take responsibility for what they've done, particularly when others have suffered as a result. But how much do we really want to know about the person responsible? Are we willing to understand what brought them to that …
When someone does something that causes serious harm, it’s natural to judge their actions. We want people to take responsibility for what they’ve done, particularly when others have suffered as a result. But how much do we really want to know about the person responsible? Are we willing to understand what brought them to that point, or do we feel that understanding them somehow diminishes the seriousness of what they’ve done?
It’s a difficult question because compassion can sometimes be mistaken for making excuses. We may feel that showing understanding towards someone who has caused harm means we’re taking their side, or overlooking the suffering of those affected. Yet surely we can recognise that someone’s actions were wrong without deciding that those actions are all there is to know about them.
Seeing the person behind the action
I recently had a conversation with Sacha Kaluri on Chocolate and Coffee Break that brought this question into focus. Sacha’s father was killed by a young drink driver at a time when she was working with young people in juvenile detention. Through her work, she had come to understand some of the circumstances that can contribute to offending, but suddenly she was experiencing the devastating consequences of someone’s actions within her own family.
During the court proceedings, Sacha heard about the young woman’s childhood and the domestic violence and trauma she had experienced. This information didn’t change what happened to her father, and Sacha made it clear she wasn’t justifying the young woman’s actions. However, it helped her understand something about the life that had brought this person to that moment. Rather than seeing only the person responsible for her father’s death, she could also see a young woman whose own experiences had shaped her life.
What makes Sacha’s response particularly interesting is that she says she forgave the young woman very quickly. For many people, that would be difficult to imagine, and understandably so. We all respond differently when someone has harmed us, and forgiveness is not something we can demand of another person. Sacha’s experience doesn’t suggest that everyone should respond as she did, but it does open a conversation about whether compassion and accountability can exist together.
Are people more than their worst actions?
We often describe people according to something they’ve done. Someone becomes a criminal, an offender, a troublemaker or a person who cannot be trusted. Sometimes these descriptions reflect genuine behaviour that needs to be addressed, but when they become the only way we see someone, we can lose sight of everything else that makes them human.
This happens in ordinary relationships as well. Someone says something offensive, makes a decision that hurts us or behaves in a way we find unacceptable. We form an opinion about them, and that opinion can become difficult to change. Even when there is more to their story, we may no longer be interested in hearing it because we’ve already decided what kind of person they are.
Understanding someone’s circumstances doesn’t mean their behaviour becomes acceptable. A difficult childhood doesn’t excuse harming another person, and personal struggles don’t remove responsibility for our choices. But knowing what has shaped a person’s life may help us respond with greater understanding, rather than letting our judgement of one action define the whole person.
We can still challenge harmful behaviour, establish boundaries and expect accountability. We can also recognise that people can make terrible decisions without believing those decisions represent everything they are or everything they might become.
When the consequences reach beyond those responsible
One of the most revealing parts of Sacha’s story came when she described attending court and meeting the family of the young woman responsible for her father’s death. By that time, the young woman had become a mother herself, and her little daughter was at the courthouse. Sacha could see that this child was about to experience the loss of her mother’s presence during important years of her life, even though she had played no part in what had happened.
Sacha told me that she wanted to give the little girl a hug. She could recognise the child’s innocence and the consequences she would face, despite everything Sacha’s own family had endured. Her concern for that little girl didn’t lessen the loss of her father or change the young woman’s responsibility. It simply showed that she could recognise suffering beyond her own family.
I think there is something important for all of us to consider here. When we see someone as entirely good or entirely bad, we can overlook the other people affected by their actions and circumstances. Families, children, and communities often carry consequences they had no part in creating, and their experiences deserve recognition too.
Making room for understanding
Many situations in everyday life benefit from being more willing to understand someone before deciding we know everything about them. We may disagree with a neighbour’s opinions, be offended by something a colleague says or find ourselves in conflict with a family member. Sometimes our concerns are entirely justified, and there may be behaviour we cannot accept. But that doesn’t mean there is nothing more to understand about the person involved.
Listening to someone’s story gives us an opportunity to see circumstances we might otherwise overlook. We may discover experiences that help explain their perspective, or we may still disagree with their choices. Either way, we’ve given ourselves the opportunity to respond to a fuller understanding of the person rather than relying entirely on our assumptions.
I don’t believe compassion requires us to abandon our judgement or ignore the harm people cause. Nor does understanding someone mean we have to forgive them, reconcile with them or allow them back into our lives. Those decisions are personal, and sometimes maintaining distance is necessary. What we can choose is whether to recognise another person’s humanity, even when we cannot accept their behaviour.
Sacha’s story offers an example of how someone can experience devastating harm and still see the person responsible as more than the worst thing they’ve done. We may not respond in the same way, but we can consider what might change in our own relationships and communities if we became more willing to understand people without assuming that understanding means agreement.
Brew the Change — Listen Anyway
This week, invite someone whose opinions or actions you strongly disagree with to share a conversation. Give them twenty minutes to explain their perspective, and listen without trying to change their mind.
You don’t have to agree with them or excuse their behaviour. The invitation is simply to understand more about the person behind the opinion or action.
You may still disagree when the conversation ends, but you’ll have given yourself the opportunity to understand something you didn’t know before.
Watch my conversation with Sacha Kaluri on Chocolate and Coffee Break:
Pour yourself a cuppa, grab your favourite chocolate and join the conversation.
Let Love Be the Loudest Voice.
Get in Touch with Us
We’d love to hear from you—share your thoughts or ask a question!






