Seeing the Diagnosis Before the Person

How much do we really know about someone when we know their diagnosis? We hear that someone has Alzheimer's, cancer, autism, a mental health condition or a disability, and almost immediately, a picture begins forming in our minds. We imagine what their life must be like, what they can and cannot do, and perhaps even …

How much do we really know about someone when we know their diagnosis?

We hear that someone has Alzheimer’s, cancer, autism, a mental health condition or a disability, and almost immediately, a picture begins forming in our minds. We imagine what their life must be like, what they can and cannot do, and perhaps even what their future holds.

Often, we do this without realising it. We may believe we are being understanding or compassionate, yet our expectations have already begun to shape the way we see that person.

And sometimes, those expectations become another burden for them to carry.

The Person We Think We Know

When someone tells us they are living with a condition, our response is often influenced by everything we have previously heard, read or experienced.

If our only experience of Alzheimer’s has been watching someone in the later stages of the disease, we may assume that everyone with that diagnosis must be experiencing something similar.

We forget that people are individuals, that conditions affect people differently, and that no diagnosis can tell us everything about someone’s abilities, personality or quality of life.

During a recent Chocolate and Coffee Break, I spoke with Jane Turner, an author, publisher and speaker who is living with Alzheimer’s disease.

Jane is articulate, engaged and continues to work with authors to bring their books into the world. She also experiences significant memory difficulties and has developed practical ways to manage her everyday life.

People are often surprised when they discover she has Alzheimer’s because she doesn’t fit the picture they have in their minds.

Yet Jane doesn’t need to fit that picture. She is simply living her own experience.

When Others Begin to See Us Differently

I encountered something similar in my conversation with Kijuan Amey, who lost his sight at 25.

Kijuan spoke about how his relationships changed after he became blind. People began responding to his blindness rather than to the person they had always known. He was still Kijuan, with the same personality, interests and desire for connection, yet the way others saw him had changed.

Jane’s experience with Alzheimer’s raises a similar question. How much of someone do we stop seeing when a diagnosis or disability becomes the first thing we notice about them?

These are very different experiences, but they reveal something about the way we relate to one another. Sometimes the greatest barrier to connection isn’t a person’s condition. It’s the assumptions we bring into the relationship.

There Is Always More to the Story

One of the most surprising things Jane shared was that, despite the difficulties she faces, she believes the quality of her life has never been better.

Following her diagnosis, Jane experienced grief, anger, disbelief and fear. But she also discovered something she had rarely allowed herself to experience during her busy working life: being fully present.

She described sitting in a park, looking at a patch of grass, and experiencing a profound sense of peace. There was nothing she needed to achieve, nowhere she needed to be, and nothing she needed to prove.

That experience changed the way she approached her life.

Of course, this is Jane’s experience. Another person living with Alzheimer’s may have a very different story. And that is precisely the point.

We cannot know what someone’s life is like simply because we know the name of their condition.

Compassion Begins With Curiosity

There is a difference between understanding someone’s circumstances and allowing those circumstances to define them.

When we focus too heavily on a diagnosis, we may begin treating the person differently. We might stop asking about their interests, assume they can no longer contribute, or direct our conversations towards their condition rather than the things that matter to them.

Sometimes, even our attempts to be helpful can leave someone feeling that we no longer see them as the person they have always been.

What if we approached people with more curiosity?

We could ask about the book they’re reading, the project they’re working on, the people they love or what has made them laugh recently.

We could allow them to tell us what they are experiencing rather than deciding for ourselves what their life must be like.

And when they do want to talk about their diagnosis, we can listen without assuming we already understand.

Seeing the Whole Person

Every one of us carries experiences that others cannot see. Some are medical diagnoses, others are grief, trauma, financial hardship, family responsibilities or private struggles.

These experiences may profoundly influence our lives, but they are never the whole of who we are.

We are also our relationships, our interests, our memories, our hopes, our humour and the countless small things that make us individuals.

When we reduce someone to a single part of their story, we risk overlooking everything else they have to offer.

Jane’s and Kijuan’s stories invite us to reconsider how we see people living with a diagnosis or disability. But the larger invitation is one we can carry into every relationship.

See the person. Be curious about their life. Allow them to show you who they are.

Because belonging begins when we recognise one another as whole human beings.


This article was inspired by my conversations with Jane Turner and Kijuan Amey on Chocolate & Coffee Break: A Compassionate Proposition.

Watch my conversation with Jane Turner: https://youtu.be/PT3kW13nvjs

Let Love Be the Loudest Voice.

Get in Touch with Us

We’d love to hear from you—share your thoughts or ask a question!


Andrea Putting

Andrea Putting