We can sit across a table from someone and believe we know something about them before they've told us very much at all. We see their appearance, hear their accent, discover where they come from or learn something about their background, and almost without realising it, we begin filling in the gaps. We draw on …
We can sit across a table from someone and believe we know something about them before they’ve told us very much at all. We see their appearance, hear their accent, discover where they come from or learn something about their background, and almost without realising it, we begin filling in the gaps. We draw on things we’ve heard, experiences we’ve had and ideas we’ve absorbed over the years. Sometimes we’re right, sometimes we’re completely wrong, and sometimes those assumptions prevent us from discovering something about another person that we could never have imagined.
In a recent conversation on Chocolate and Coffee Break, I sat down with Aboriginal artist and cultural educator Michael Connolly. Michael has spent decades sharing his culture through art and conversation, yet he still encounters people who question his Aboriginal identity because he doesn’t look the way they expect an Aboriginal person to look.
Think about what happens in that moment. Someone who knows their family, their ancestry and their connection to Country finds themselves being questioned by a person who has already formed an opinion based on appearance. Michael could simply dismiss those encounters, but he often chooses to share his story, giving people an opportunity to understand something they may never have considered.
It raises an important question about how much of our understanding of other people has been shaped by stories that were never theirs to begin with. We inherit ideas from our families, communities, education, media and the conversations happening around us. Over time, those ideas can become so familiar that we stop questioning where they came from. Then we meet someone whose lived experience doesn’t fit what we thought we knew, and we have a choice about whether we’re prepared to listen.
The Importance of Knowing Our Own Stories
During our conversation, Michael shared the experience of a young Aboriginal woman who came into his shop searching for answers about her identity. Her family had denied their Aboriginal heritage, leaving her uncertain about where she belonged. Michael helped her explore her family connections and encouraged her to visit her ancestral Country, where she met with Elders and heard stories about her family. When she returned, she had a different understanding of who she was and where she came from.
There is something deeply human about wanting to understand our own story, although the meaning of that connection is not the same for everyone. For Aboriginal people, connection to Country carries cultural and spiritual significance that goes far beyond simply knowing where previous generations lived. Yet many of us can recognise the desire to understand our ancestry, the people who came before us and the experiences that have shaped our families.
I shared with Michael my recent experience of travelling to Estonia and visiting the place where my grandfather grew up. Standing on that land brought a different dimension to a family story I had carried for years. It wasn’t the same experience as Michael’s connection to Country, and it didn’t need to be. We could share something meaningful about our different experiences without suggesting they were equivalent.
I think this is something we sometimes lose when talking about difference. We can become so concerned with finding common ground that we overlook the importance of allowing another person’s experience to be different from our own. We don’t have to find ourselves in every story to recognise that it matters to the person telling it.
When Our Expectations Get in the Way
Michael’s artwork offers another example of how expectations can limit our understanding. People sometimes assume Aboriginal art should look a particular way, often expecting dot painting. When they encounter Michael’s work, which tells stories of Country through his own artistic expression, they question why it looks different from what they imagined.
He paints the Country he knows, including its animals, plants and the stories connected to the land. His artwork reflects his own experience and cultural knowledge, yet people can become so attached to their expectations that they struggle to recognise something outside the picture they’ve already formed.
We do this in many areas of life. We have ideas about what a successful person looks like, how someone from a particular culture might behave, what people of different generations believe or how someone should respond to an experience we’ve never had. Often these ideas aren’t formed through deliberate prejudice. They’re simply understandings we’ve absorbed without having much reason to question them.
The difficulty comes when we allow those assumptions to speak more loudly than the person standing in front of us. We may think we’re listening while we’re actually comparing everything they say with what we already believe. And when their experience doesn’t fit, we can find ourselves questioning their story rather than questioning our assumptions.
Listening doesn’t mean we have to agree with everything another person says. We can ask questions, explore differences and have conversations that challenge both of us. But there is a difference between approaching someone with genuine curiosity and approaching them with a conclusion we’ve already reached.
Bringing Our Stories Together
One of the important parts of my conversation with Michael came when we talked about reconciliation. He spoke about bringing our stories together around the coffee table, using the words, “Your story, our story, my story, everyone’s story.”
I appreciate that he wasn’t asking anyone to abandon their own story to make room for another. We each bring our history, our experiences and our understanding of the world into a conversation. Those experiences may be very different, and some may include painful histories that others have never had to confront.
There are also stories that have been heard far more often than others. Some have shaped the way entire communities are understood, while the people whose lives are being described have had little opportunity to speak for themselves. When we make room for those voices, we may discover that what we thought we knew was incomplete or that the story is far more complicated than we had imagined.
I don’t believe that bringing our stories together means we’ll always find agreement. There are real differences between us, and some conversations will remain difficult. But we can recognise another person’s humanity without having to share their experiences or reach the same conclusions. We can acknowledge that their story belongs to them and that we have something to learn by hearing it in their own words.
Perhaps one of the challenges of our time is that we have access to more information and opinions about other people than ever before, yet we can still go through our lives without hearing directly from those whose experiences are different from ours. We can read countless comments about a community, follow debates about its place in society and form strong opinions without ever listening to someone who belongs to it.
Whose Story Haven’t We Heard?
At the end of my conversation with Michael, I offered a Brew the Change invitation that I hope people will take beyond the episode.
Choose a person or culture you realise you know mostly through what you’ve heard from others, or about whom you may have formed assumptions. Find one story told in their own voice. You might read a personal account, watch an interview or sit down with someone who is willing to share their experience. You could also choose another episode of Chocolate and Coffee Break featuring a guest from a background different from your own.
I’m interested in what happens when we make a deliberate choice to hear from people rather than simply hearing about them. We may discover something that challenges our understanding, recognise an experience that feels familiar or encounter a perspective we’ve never considered. We may also find ourselves with more questions than answers, and I think there’s room for that too.
Michael’s invitation to bring our stories together around the coffee table is one we can put into practice in ordinary ways. We don’t need a formal event or a carefully planned discussion. We can begin by making space for someone to tell us something about their life and being willing to hear it.
I’d love to know whose story has helped you understand something about the world that you didn’t understand before. It might have come through a book, a film, a conversation or an unexpected encounter. Perhaps sharing those experiences is another way we can introduce one another to voices that deserve to be heard.
Watch my conversation with Michael Connolly on Chocolate and Coffee Break:
Pour yourself a cuppa, grab your favourite chocolate and join the conversation.
Let Love Be the Loudest Voice.
Get in Touch with Us
We’d love to hear from you—share your thoughts or ask a question!






